Thursday, December 1, 2016

Another Night: Unreleased Recordings, 1961 - 2016 (Volume Two)

Another Night, 1961 - 2016
Curiosities & Miscellany
Volume Two

Two Trains Running - Live - Montreal - July 2, 1962
Not Fade Away - Live - New York - July 26, 1999
Jokerman - Outtake - Infidels Sessions - 1983
If You See Her, Say Hello - Alternative Version - World Tour Rehearsal - 1978
Blackjack Davey - Live - Mansfield - September 12, 1993
Tom Turkey - Outtake - Pat Garett & Billy The Kid Sessions - 1973
Shake - Tour Rehearsal - 1985
The Lonesome Death Of Hattie Carroll - Live - Houston - November 12, 1981
Gates Of Eden - Live - Paris - July 6, 1978
1952 Vincent Black Lightning - Live - Clarkston - July 14, 2013
You Really Got A Hold On Me - Outtake - Buckets Of Rain Session - 1975
The Mighty Quinn - Live - Southampton - August 19, 2002
Simple Twist Of Fate - Live - Hattiesburg - May 1, 1976
Sidewalks, Fences & Walls - Outtake - Down In The Groove Sessions - 1987
Like A Rolling Stone - Live - Avignon - July 25, 1981
Forever Young - Live - Toronto - August 7, 1997

Welcome to the final installment of The Thousand Highways Collection. The previous volume of this series, Another Night Volume One, established the formula for this volume - a compilation of assorted curiosities and notable performances that did not make it onto more thematically coherent titles. Volume Two has some real humdingers, so open up those ears and listen in.

"Two Trains Running" is an old Muddy Waters track, and Dylan does it justice in this early solo performance from Montreal's Finjan Club. As with many of the singer's earliest uptempo songs, he powers along the tempo with a rhythmic tapping that's luckily been preserved by this crisp recording.

"Not Fade Away" is another cover, this time originating with Buddy Holly. Holly had been quite influential to the young Bob Dylan, as indicated by the Martin Scorcese's 2005 documentary, No Direction Home. Still, few of Holly's own compositions had been played by Dylan over the years. The Never-Ending Tour altered this, though, and a number of Holly's tracks entered the setlist between 1988 and 2016; none appeared more often, though, than the heavily rhythmic "Not Fade Away." This rendition from the much-loved Tramps show in 1999 is particularly well-executed.

"Jokerman" was the lead song on 1983's Infidels, and became quite a classic in its own right. This alternative version offers a very different vocal performance and a handful of lyrical variants. Instrumentally, it's quite similar to the final version.

"If You See Her, Say Hello" may sound familiar, as a roughly identical arrangement appeared on an earlier Thousand Highways compilation covering rehearsals from 1971 to 1989. This version, though, features a slightly more prominent harpsichord and violin, which improves the strangely baroque sound of the arrangement. It's a shame this didn't stay in the set past the first weeks of 1978's World Tour.

"Blackjack Davey" was one of the standout songs on Good As I Been To You in 1992, but only appeared live the following year. It's a very old song, and was also performed by Bob Dylan at the start of his career in 1961. Like "Barbara Allen" to "Scarlet Town," "Blackjack Davey" served as an inspiration for "Tin Angel" on Dylan's Tempest record from 2012. This arrangement is interesting, since live versions from 1993 are the only time when Dylan played the song with (limited) instrumental backing.

"Tom Turkey" is an outtake from 1973's Pat Garrett & Billy The Kid. Like other songs recorded for that soundtrack, it's effectively an excerpt from the "Billy" narrative with some unique instrumentation. Mostly instrumental, it includes only two verses of the "Billy" along with some intriguing harmonica fills.

"Shake" was an original Bob Dylan composition based roughly on Roy Head's "Treat Her Right." It was played briefly in 1985 and 1986 at the first Farm Aid show and on tour with Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers. This is the clearest recording, though even here the lyrics seem unfinished. It's quite groovy, if nothing else.

"The Lonesome Death Of Hattie Carroll" is one of only a handful of performances of this song from my favorite Bob Dylan touring year - 1981. Like most of the year, it features a compelling, rich vocal performance and a loose arrangement.

"Gates Of Eden" was played very rarely from 1965 to 1988, and one of the finest outings for the song was as a solo performance in 1978. This spot of the setlist was typically reserved for "It Ain't Me, Babe," but other classic 1960s tracks featured a few times, including "Fourth Time Around" and "A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall." Unfortunately, only "Gates Of Eden" was preserved with a lovely recording. Luckily, the performance is excellent.

"1952 Vincent Black Lightning" barely saw the light of day. It was recorded by an intrepid amateur taper in 2013, and only began to circulate two years later in a handful of alternative mixes. There are some chatty audience members near the tape recorder, but they do little to reduce the passion of this unique one-time performance of Richard Thompson's motorcycle epic.

"You Really Got A Hold On Me" was played by Bob Dylan and Bette Midler in the midst of a recording session for Midler's Songs For The New Depression. Much of the session consists of shaky takes on a rewrite of "Buckets Of Rain," but the two spontaneously burst into an equally shaky (yet delightful) performance of this Smokey Robinson gem. Bob Dylan has spoken of his admiration for Robinson, but this is one of the only times he played a song written by that American icon.

"The Mighty Quinn" is one of the most celebrated songs from The Basement Tapes, but the writer only sang it live a few times over the past fifty years. Other versions can be found elsewhere on The Thousand Highways Collection, but this is the only time that the song featured Dylan's excellent backing band harmonizing as it did on bluegrass classics from 1998 to 2002.

"Simple Twist Of Fate" is a heartbreaking song, but rarely has it been performed with the pathos instilled on this night in Hattiesburg during the Rolling Thunder Revue. It sounds fairly similar to the style used to great effect earlier in the tour on "If You See Her, Say Hello," though this song is not nearly as re-written as its Blood On The Tracks companion.

"Sidewalks, Fences & Walls" did not circulate for decades, but this outtake from Down In The Groove finally appeared in the taper community during the 2000s. It's a straightforward soul song infused with depth by a passionate vocal performance. The sound is less than stellar, as it only circulates as a fairly compromised lossy recording, but we should be grateful that it appeared at all.

"Like A Rolling Stone" is my favorite rendition of a Bob Dylan classic. It's not quite as tight as earlier performances from the 1981 tour, but it makes up for that looseness with one of Dylan's most inventive, passionate, shredded vocal tracks you'll ever hear. You can point to moments like this as one of the reasons that the singer's voice deepened and lost some of the range it displayed in the 1970s, but at least we received incredible recordings like this one from the singer pushing his art outside of his comfort zone.

"Forever Young," a sentimental song written by the singer for his child, is as appropriate an ending as you could ask for on this long listening journey. Happily, it features one of Dylan's unique lead guitar performances and a touching harmonica solo.

I hope you've enjoyed listening to these as much as I've enjoyed researching, seeking out recordings, and finding the very best tracks to remaster and compile for this collection. It's been lovely, and until next our paths cross, keep yourself healthy and listen to some good tunes.



  1. Are you really retiring? Thank you so much for all you've done.

  2. Thank you for a wonderful work!

  3. With the latest compilation, you have given me a big folder on my harddrive with Bob Dylan's work right from the beginnings of his career up to his latest shows.I really appreciate the way you provided insight into his music and apart from having lots of fun listening, I did learn a lot through your compilations and your writings. A big, big thank you for this! I do hope that Bob will keep touring for a very long time as it might tempt you to keep posting some recordings again?

  4. Thanks for all the compilations over the years.

  5. Genial!!
    Hermoso regalo de fin de año!

  6. "Tell me it isn't true..."
    Extreme Thanks for enriching this Bob fans roio collection my friend.
    You've done an outstanding work here. Gave us all a boost of excitement for the start of each month. Good luck in whatever you do next..
    Blessings on you.

    Bruce Mulle'

  7. Thank you. You're always welcome back anytime.

    Allan rosenberg

  8. Looks wonderful yet again. Thank you!

  9. A marvelous curation, enhanced by the obvious passion that you brought to the task. Many thanks for your labors, and Godspeed.

  10. Thanks for everything you've generously shared with us over the years. It's been a fun and enlightening ride.

  11. What a journey! Many thanks for all the wonderful curation.

  12. Thank you so much CS. As has already been said the curatorial nature of your compilations has been a sheer joy to own and collect for which we offer our thanks but somehow I cannot bear the idea there will be no more. Please give us hope that you may change your mind at some point maybe in the future? Is possible?

    1. There may be future ones if I'm inspired by a new tour or some newly circulating recordings, but I've actually run out of thematic or chronological content to cover, haha. I do appreciate the kind words, and I've enjoyed making these, but as the final roundup suggests, I'm pretty much just down to the less noteworthy material; it's best not to dilute the otherwise consistent series with less cohesive albums.

  13. thank you for all your work! can't tell you how much I've appreciated it.

  14. Let us know what you think of the new 1966 box set when you've had time to absorb it.

    Allan Rosenberg

  15. Thank you very much for all the music you made available to us, and the great notes and artworks!

  16. Many thanks for the wonderful music you shared.

  17. Thank you very much CWS! I had an amazing time listening to your compilations (still have a few to catch up) and discovering so many gems throughout Bob Dylan life in the studio and on the road :)
    Hope you will change your mind sooner or later :D

  18. I can't thank you enough for the TH collection. It's a major contribution. Like a Real Real Bootleg Series. I will miss looking forward to the first of every month for a new TH.

    Also, if you're taking requests, I'd love to see a TH Do It Yourself Playlist for the Live '66 box.

    Thanks for all you've done. We will be enjoying the benefits of your work for many years.

    1. Good call on the DIY Playlist for 1966. I've got ideas for a few more of these, and Live '66 had crossed my mind (given how often I listen to my own Cutting Edge DIY Playlist). Unfortunately, I had to choose between saving for the 1966 box set and saving for the upcoming Nintendo Switch, and I'm sorry to say that the Switch won out, haha. So it might be a bit before I get my hands on the '66 recordings. Expecting Rain conversations have me more hyped now than before they were released, but I'll just have to be patient.

    2. thanks for all your work, thought, erudition, determination - did you get your 1996 box yet?

    3. @Pete Silverton - Haven't picked up the 1966 Box yet. I'd really like to, but money is stretched thin and my next big purchase is the new Nintendo console in a couple of months. Hopefully I'll be able to grab the 1966 set by the end of 2017.

  19. Many thanks again and Happy Christmas and a good New Year to you and yours! Cheers!!

  20. Sorry to hear that this is the end, but thankful for everything along the way

  21. Can you do a compilation of songs sang in the "upsing" style? I think I remember from another post you said you don't like upsinging? Maybe make one for those of us who like the style?

    1. This is a neat idea! I'm not much a fan of the style, and I gather that that's the overall consensus, but it would be nice for such a thing to exist, since folks like you enjoyed it. That said, I doubt I'd be the man for the job, as I'm both done with this series and admittedly not aware of what would make one upsinging track preferable to another. Thanks for the suggestion, though!

  22. Always wondered why you never tackled the tour Dylan did with The Grateful Dead in 1987, there must be some good performances :D

    1. Funny enough, this is one of those lost compilations. I did tackle the subject, but couldn't put together a final product I was happy with - the tour really was that bad. A 1987 version of "Chimes of Freedom" almost made it onto "Another Night - Volume 1" or "Volume 2," but I ultimately abandoned it on the cutting room floor.

  23. I've just today read that you've posted your last set and want to express my appreciation for all your well performed work in getting these sets, set lists, commentaries and your upkeep of the blog. It's unfortunate in a case like this that the name of the form is 'blog'. But maybe its because out of this type of thing that life comes.. .
    I was scouting around the site looking for what I wanted but hadn't yet downloaded and noticed, your enthusiasm for Mr. Dylan's harmonica work on 'Let's Stick Together' and again appreciated your insight into his work.
    Best wishes for making good use and full enjoyment of the effects of the good karma that should be coming your way. Mille merci!

  24. Thank you. I have really enjoyed the ride!

  25. Tom Turkey sounds more like another alternate take of Billy?

  26. Ahhh, Gates of Eden. Simply spellbinding. I'm currently updating my chronological playlists to include downloads from your site and some other unofficial stuff I've got lying around on CD. 1978 is my current focus and I went in meaning to be selective....but pretty much everything I could find on here was a keeper. Thanks once again for your generosity.